So today, I thought, "How well does a QB fare against a team that he previously won a Super Bowl with?"
The answer: Not too shabby. Here's my attempt at a comprehensive list, but since this is just for fun, I make no claims that there isn't an error or two. The record in parentheses indicates the QB's record on the road -- in other words, at his old stomping grounds.
Kurt Warner vs. the Rams: 5-2 (3-0)
Joe Montana vs. the 49ers: 1-0 (0-0)
Jim McMahon vs. the Bears: 2-0 (1-0) (both with the Vikings, ignoring this one-attempt game)
Jeff Hostetler vs. the Giants: 1-1-1 (1-1)
Trent Dilfer vs. the Ravens: 0-2 (0-1) (ignoring this game, where he threw just one pass -- hey, remember when a lot of people were up in arms about the Ravens letting their Super Bowl-winning quarterback go?)
Brad Johnson vs. the Bucs: 1-0 (0-0)
Ken Stabler vs. the Raiders: 0-1 (0-1) (in a playoff game, no less)
And some guy vs. the Packers: 1-0 (0-0) -- no, not Bart Starr
That's a total record of 11-6-1, including 5-3 at the QB's old stadium. Don't talk to me about small sample size, that's great news for this weekend!
Frankly, I'm a little surprised that it hasn't happened more often. If not for Kurt Warner winning a Super Bowl in, essentially, his first year in the league and then moving on to play for a team in his old team's division, we'd only have 11 such games instead of the 18 we currently have. If only we'd gotten Brett about five years ago...
I'm looking forward to Tom Brady's career with the Jets in 2013-2016.
Tuesday Open Thread: March 21, 2017
1 week ago